L4M3 Commercial Contracting Questions and Answers

NEC - New Engineering Contracts is a family of contracts invented by Institute of Civil Engineers. The contracts are suitable for procuring a diverse range of works, services and supply, ranging from major framework projects through to minor works and the purchase of supplies and goods.

FIDIC is a French language acronym for Fédération Internationale Des Ingénieurs-Conseils, which means the international federation of consulting engineers. It was started in 1913 by the trio of France, Belgium and Switzerland. The United Kingdom joined the Federation in 1949. FIDIC is headquartered in Switzerland and now boasts of membership from over 60 different countries. FIDIC published its first contract, titled The Form of contract for works of Civil Engineering construction, in 1957. As the title indicated, this first contract was aimed at the Civil Engineering sector and it soon became known for the colour of its cover, and thus, The Red Book. It has become the tradition that FIDIC contracts are known in popular parlance by the colour of their cover. This first contract by FIDIC was undertaken jointly with the International federation of Building and Public works. FIDIC’s concerted effort at achieving broad consultation and acceptance of its contract forms has seen subsequent editions of its contracts being ratified by the International Federation of Asian and Western Pacific Contractors Association, Associated General Contractors of America and the Inter-American Federation of the Construction Industry, Multilateral Development Banks among others. Because of the broad support it enjoys, FIDIC contracts are the foremost contracts in international construction.

The Joint Contracts Tribunal, also known as the JCT, produces standard forms of contract for construction, guidance notes and other standard documentation for use in the construction industry in the United Kingdom. From its establishment in 1931, JCT has expanded the number of contributing organisations.

IMechE/IET: Institution of Mechanical Engineers/Institution of Engineering and Technology - two separate institutes that issue jointly agreed model forms covering the design, supply and installation of electrical, electronic and mechanical plant including special conditions for the ancillary development of software.

A simple definition of consideration is as follows – an exchange between the parties which results in a benefit to one party, and a detriment to the other. The case of Currie v Misa (1874) LR 10 Ex 153 provides an apt description of this:

“A valuable consideration, in the sense of the law, may consist either in some right, interest, profit, or benefit accruing to the one party, or some forbearance, detriment, loss, or responsibility, given, suffered, or undertaken by the other.”

A practical example of this can be found by examining a simple contract. Party A offers £500 to Party B, who in exchange will fit his car with a new engine. Party A receives the benefit of his car being fixed, whilst Party B incurs the detriment of having to take time, effort, and perhaps expenses to fix the car.

In the contract term, the buyer agrees to pay the contractor the cost of doing project plus a profit. This is an example of cost-plus pricing arrangement.

On the other hand, "Fixed-pricing arrangement" often refers to lump-sum contract or supply/service contract with fixed price. "Incentive pricing arrangement" and "Gain-share/pain-share arrangement" have the same meaning. In this type of arrangement, both supplier and buyer agree on a target (it can be cost, or lead time, or quality, etc). Once the supplier reaches that target, it will be rewarded with a portion of the gain that the buyer gets, and will pay the price if it fails.

Implementation is a substantive requirement which covers the following areas:

- Will there be a need to train the staff to use the equipment?

- Are there integration requirements with other systems or processes?

- How will this work?

- What are the timescales?

- Are detailed method statements required?

Consultation requirements regards to explicitness of compliance with any national or local legal requirements

Hire purchase is an arrangement for buying expensive consumer goods, where the buyer makes an initial down payment and pays the balance plus interest in installments. Ownership is not transferred until the end of the agreement, hire purchase plans offer more protection to the vendor than other sales or leasing methods for unsecured items. That's because the items can be repossessed more easily should the buyer be unable to keep up with the repayments.

The answer is that Company B has the right to take repossession of the lorry.

The organisation should have an overarching strategies or policies which sets out the social and environmental objectives to be pursued via procurement and the supply chain generally. Some of these will be about the specification, but that must be tied in other aspects of the sourcing strategy. These objectives, policies and strategies can be found in corporate social responsibility policy.

The license can be amended during its lifespan. However, in this case, it already has a clause allowing for mechanism of variation which sets out who can authorise changes and prohibits any oral variation. Therefore, the agreement between Rock's director and MWB credit controller is not an effective variation to the license.

Developing and using generic specifications is as import in the sustainable procurement process as it is in the traditional procurement process. During this stage, human/labour rights and environmental performance criteria should be translated into specifications that meet specific requirements of the specified outcome, desired by the procurement action.

The specification stage is key to all types of contract. Building in environmental and social considerations at this early stage, provides a clear indication to suppliers that sustainability is important to the UN organization. Consider available alternatives which are less environmentally and socially damaging. Consider all the phases of a product’s life cycle (e.g. production, transportation, maintenance, disposal, etc) when determining its cost and environmental impact. Assess the overall environmental and social integrity of suppliers by looking at their policies and practices.

Specifications which are output-based rather than input-based can increase supplier innovation, reduce waste and minimise harmful social and environmental impacts.

In order to form a contract to come into being, there are five conditions:

- Offer

- Acceptance

- Consideration

- Intention to be legally bound

- Capacity to contract

One-off contract is the type of contract that relates to a single purchase. One-off contracts can be used for goods, services or works. One-off contract can be simple (such as buying a small number of office stationeries) or complex (such as a construction project or buying an aircraft).

A one-off contract lasts “until completion of the obligations of the parties”. The performance is unlikely to be improved during contract performance since the duration is relatively shorter than framework agreement or call-off contract.

Ad-hoc purchase is an item bought for a single and non-recurring use or purpose. Ad-hoc purchase is a type of one-off contract.

A service-level agreement (SLA) is a commitment between a service provider and a client. Particular aspects of the service – quality, availability, responsibilities – are agreed between the service provider and the service user. The most common component of an SLA is that the services should be provided to the customer as agreed upon in the contract.

A customer service charter is a document that outlines how an organization promises to work with its customers along with providing insights into how an organization operates.

A service guarantee is a marketing tool service firms have increasingly been using to reduce consumer risk perceptions, signal quality, differentiate a service offering, and to institutionalize and professionalize their internal management of customer complaint and service recovery.

A lease is a contractual arrangement calling for the lessee (user) to pay the lessor (owner) for use of an asset. Some characteristics of Leases are:

- The right to use the lessor’s asset is granted in exchange for a fee called the lease payment.

- The lease payments are usually paid in installments.

- Leases may be long- or short-term.

- At its inception a lease agreement constitutes a mutually unperformed contract

Though the ownership of the asset is not transferred to the lessee, some responsibilities and risks do. The lessor and lessee may negotiate on who is responsible on maintenance, insurance, etc.

An invitation to treat is an action inviting other parties to make an offer to form a contract. These actions may sometimes appear to be offers themselves, and the difference can sometimes be difficult to determine. The distinction is important because accepting an offer creates a binding contract while "accepting" an invitation to treat is actually making an offer.

One simple test to distinguish an offer and an invitation to treat is to ask what this statement will become when it is accepted. Now we apply this test to four options:

- Tender bid: Tender bid is submitted by a supplier to an invitation to tender from the buyer. It states the specific quantity, price and other elements. If buyer accepts the bid, there will be a contract between them. Therefore, a tender bid is an offer.

- Purchase order: Purchase order which is sent by a buyer will state the items, the quantity, the price and terms and conditions. If supplier accepts the purchase order, there will also be a contract between two parties. It is also an offer.

- Price list: Price list is prepared by a supplier. The price list often states the items and unit price. If a buyer accepts it, the contract has not yet been formed since the contract scope has not yet been decided. It is an invitation to treat.

- Invoice: Invoice is often sent after a contract is formed. It is in fact a request for payment, neither offer nor invitation to treat.

Standards are incorporated into specifications by simply cross-refering to the relevant standard by its number and date of publication. It is important to include the date of publication. All standards are reviewed from time to time and their content changes. The absence of the publication date will lead to disrupts over which version of the standard actually applies to the contract.

Once a valid acceptance takes place, a binding contract is formed. It is therefore important to know what constitutes a valid acceptance in order to establish if the parties are bound by the agreement. There are three main rules relating to acceptance:

1. The acceptance must be communicated to the offeree.

2. The terms of the acceptance must exactly match the terms of the offer.

3. The agreement must be certain.

Among the answers:

"The person says that she will think about it overnight" does not match the terms of the offer. The offeree does not assure that she will accept the offer.

"The person asks for a lower price": This is a counter-offer.

"The person states that she is able to pay the offered price" is not certain. The offeree merely provides information on her financial ability.

Without further explanation, a schedule may be deemed to form an integral part of the obligations of either or both parties. Obviously, the scope or binding nature of such schedule depends on the way it is referred to in the obligatory language of the main agreement. Accordingly, merely attaching the general terms and conditions of sale without explaining to which part of the sale they apply or which provisions apply does not subject a sale pursuant to the body text of the agreement to those general terms and conditions.

Subcontracting is the practice of assigning, or outsourcing, part of the obligations and tasks under a contract to another party known as a subcontractor.

Social and environmental criteria are increasingly encouraged in public sector contracting. In the UK, The Public Services (Social Value) Act 2012 encourages public organising to apply social and environmental criteria in contract.

Social and environmental criteria are increasingly encouraged in public sector contracting. In the UK, The Public Services (Social Value) Act 2012 encourages public organising to apply social and environmental criteria in contract.

When parties do not negotiate face-to-face, a key QUESTION NO: becomes when things like acceptances, rejections and revocations take effect. The general rule is that acceptances are effective on dispatch (when they are mailed). Everything else becomes effective when the offeror actually receives them. This idea is codified by the “mailbox rule” which states that acceptance is effective on dispatch, even before the offeror has received it. (The one minor exception to this rule involves option contracts for which acceptances are not effective until they are received by the offeror.)

Article 2 of CISG states that:

This Convention does not apply to sales:

(a) of goods bought for personal, family or household use, unless the seller, at any time before or at the conclusion of the contract, neither knew nor ought to have known that the goods were bought for any such use;

(b) by auction;

(c) on execution or otherwise by authority of law;

(d) of stocks, shares, investment securities, negotiable instruments or money;

(e) of ships, vessels, hovercraft or aircraft;

(f) of electricity.

LO 1, AC 1.2

According to the scenario, customers' demand changes regularly but the construction project commencement often delays. If the contractor and the customer mutually sign a legally binding contract too soon long before the commencement, the contractor may suffer poor cash flow (it must buy the materials first but has to wait for long time to be paid). A framework agreement may help both parties.

A framework agreement is a formal agreement between two organisations that is intended to become legally binding in the event that a contract is created.

A framework agreement could benefit the both parties in the following ways:

- At the time of signing, the framework agreement has not yet become a legally binding contract. The contractor and client only agree on the principles of future contracts (such as whether the work can be subcontracted or how payment will be proceeded). A well structured framework agreement will allow both parties to apply changes before contract commencement, especially regarding price and quality.

- The framework agreement assures a certainty between the contractor and client.

- The administrative works is reduced under a framework agreement.

There are a number of ways for an offer to be terminated. They are events that may occur after an offer has been made which bring it to an end so that it can no longer be accepted. An offer is terminated in the following circumstances:

1. Revocation

2. Rejection

3. Lapse of time

4. Conditional Offer (or Failure of Conditionality)

5. Operation of law

6. Death

7. Acceptance

8. Illegality

There are two main types of specification: performance specification and conformance specification (sometimes called prescriptive or technical specifications).

Performance specifications have following features:

- Focus on outputs

- Set out result to be achieved

- The 'what', not the 'how'

- Give supplier flexibility to present solutions that the buyer may not have considered

Product Liability Insurance is a form of general liability insurance meant to protect a business from financial and legal consequences as a result of bodily injury or property damage due to the use of the business’s sold goods or products. Situations that are typically covered by Product Liability Insurance may include:

- A customer harms herself because of the faulty packaging on one of your products

- A drapery set that a customer purchased from your business was highly flammable and caught on fire, eventually damaging her entire kitchen

- A customer with a severe allergy finds trace amounts of tree nuts in your homemade gourmet muffins

- A homemade house cleaner that you sell damaged one of your customer’s entire hardwood floor

- A customer becomes sick with food poisoning after eating old shellfish at your restaurant, goes to the hospital, and incurs medical costs caused by your contaminated food products

- A customer’s pet becomes ill from ingesting some lining in a pet toy product that you sell

In the scenario above, the supermarket is purchasing and reselling house cleaner, which can be covered by product liability insurance.

Public liability insurance is a type of business insurance that covers the cost of claims made by the public that happen in connection with the business activities.

Professional indemnity (PI) insurance is a commercial policy designed to protect business owners, freelancers and the self-employed if clients claim a service is inadequate.

Quantum meruit means "the amount he deserves" or "as much as he has earned". In most cases it denotes a claim for a reasonable sum in respect of services or goods supplied to the defendant.

An action in quantum meruit is available to recover money for services or goods supplied to a defendant in circumstances where the claimant is not recompensed by performing his obligations or supplying the goods. The claimant must usually show that the defendant expressly or impliedly requested or freely accepted the services or goods in question. Depending on the facts, the claimant might find it difficult to prove how much the claimant is entitled to receive under the principle of quantum meruit.

A claim for quantum meruit cannot arise if the parties have a contract to pay an agreed sum. In such circumstances, the parties' relationship is governed by the law of contract. However, a claim for quantum meruit may arise where the parties:

- Have not agreed a contract, or there is a so-called quasi-contract. For example, the parties may have agreed some of the contractual terms, but may have failed to reach an agreement on an essential term, such as price.

- Have not fixed a price for the services or goods supplied.

- Have an agreement to pay a reasonable sum for the services or goods supplied.

- Have agreed a scope of work under the original contract and the work carried out falls outside that scope.